Service Law

Article 30 and Service Matters in Minority Schools and Colleges in U.P.: Who Appoints, Who Dismisses, and What the State May Regulate

By Shashank Shri Tripathi, AdvNovember 17, 202616 min read
Featured illustration for Article 30 and Service Matters in Minority Schools and Colleges in U.P.: Who Appoints, Who Dismisses, and What the State May Regulate
Article 30(1) lets the management of a minority school or college in Uttar Pradesh choose its Principal and teachers from among qualified persons and dismiss staff without the DIOS's prior approval. The State may still fix qualifications, pay and fair procedure. This article explains Section 16-FF, the St. John Inter College ruling, the Supreme Court's limits, and the open question raised by the 2023 Education Service Selection Commission Act.

Practice area: Service matters at the Allahabad High Court: suspension, inquiry, pension and regularisation

On 30 March 2001 the Supreme Court decided a question on which the Allahabad High Court's Full Bench had gone the other way: must the Committee of Management of a minority intermediate college in Uttar Pradesh obtain the District Inspector of Schools' prior approval before it dismisses a teacher? In C/M St. John Inter College v. Girdhari Singh, (2001) 4 SCC 296, the answer was no. Twenty-five years later, the question troubling minority managements in U.P. is a different one. It is no longer only who may dismiss a teacher, but who may choose one. Since the Uttar Pradesh Education Service Selection Commission Act, 2023 came into force on 21 August 2023, its definition of "institution" expressly names aided minority colleges and aided minority intermediate colleges, high schools and junior high schools.

This article makes two points, on the law as it stands on 17 November 2026. First, Article 30(1) of the Constitution still secures to the management of a minority school or college two things that the State cannot take away through an unguided power: the choice of its Principal and teachers from among qualified persons, and disciplinary control over its staff without an officer's veto. Second, the State may prescribe qualifications, pay, service conditions and fair procedure, and for an aided institution it may go further; but how far it may go in taking the selection of teachers out of the management's hands is the least settled question in this field, in Uttar Pradesh and in the Supreme Court. The first point decides most ordinary disputes. The second will decide how much of that protection remains.

What Article 30 Protects

Article 30(1) gives all minorities, whether based on religion or language, the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. Article 30(2) adds that the State, in granting aid, shall not discriminate against an institution because it is under the management of a minority. An "aided" institution, in U.P. usage, is one whose sanctioned staff are paid by the State. The "Committee of Management" is the body that runs the institution, and the District Inspector of Schools (DIOS) is the officer who supervises recognised intermediate colleges in the district.

The protection belongs only to an institution that a minority has established and administers. In Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal, 2024 INSC 856 (8 November 2024), a seven-Judge Bench, by a majority of 4:3, overruled S. Azeez Basha (1967) to the extent it held that an institution incorporated by a statute cannot be one established by a minority. The Court laid down how the question of establishment is to be examined and left the status of AMU itself to a regular Bench. For a school or college in U.P., any dispute about minority character begins with the institution's founding record and the order by which its minority status was recognised.

The Supreme Court summarised the governing principles from T.M.A. Pai Foundation (2002) in Secretary, Malankara Syrian Catholic College v. T. Jose, (2007) 1 SCC 386, at paragraph 19. The right to administer includes the right to choose the governing body and to appoint teaching and non-teaching staff. It is not absolute, and it does not include a right to maladminister. The State may prescribe standards of education, eligibility and qualifications, and service conditions. State aid does not change the minority character of an institution, and the conditions attached to aid must not dilute the right itself.

The Choice of the Principal

Of everything Article 30 protects in service matters, the choice of the head of the institution has been guarded most closely. In Malankara (paragraph 27), the Supreme Court described the freedom to choose the Principal as a vital facet of the right to administer, and held that the receipt of aid makes no difference to it. The management may select the person it considers most suited, provided he has the qualifications the State prescribes.

That proviso does real work. In Imtiyaz Ahamad v. State of U.P., Writ-A No. 11509 of 2023, decided on 31 October 2023 (2023:AHC:207384), the Committee of Management of an aided minority intermediate college in Ghazipur gave officiating charge of Principal to a lecturer who completed the required ten years of teaching only after the vacancy arose. The Allahabad High Court set aside the DIOS's approval. The Committee, the Court said, is free to choose whom it wants to officiate, but the right is not unfettered (paragraph 33); eligibility is judged on the date the vacancy arises (paragraph 30). Article 30 protects the choice among qualified persons. It does not make an unqualified choice valid.

The Choice of Teachers Under Section 16-FF

For aided minority intermediate colleges, Section 16-FF of the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921 has long provided the route. A Selection Committee nominated by the Committee of Management selects the teacher, under the procedure in Regulation 17 of Chapter II of the Regulations, and the selected candidate cannot be appointed until the DIOS approves the proposal. Under Section 16-FF(4), the DIOS shall not withhold approval where the selected person has the prescribed minimum qualifications and is otherwise eligible.

The Supreme Court read these provisions in State of U.P. v. Rachna Hills, Civil Appeal No. 1882 of 2023, decided on 27 April 2023. Three points from that judgment matter in practice. Approval is mandatory, so a selected candidate acquires no vested right to appointment before it (paragraphs 19 and 21). Neither the Act nor the Regulations provide for "deemed" approval if the DIOS sits on the papers (paragraphs 23 and 24). And the DIOS's duty not to withhold approval applies where the prescribed selection procedure has in fact been followed (paragraph 25). If approval is refused, the management may represent to the Regional Deputy Director of Education within three weeks under Section 16-FF(5) (paragraph 26).

The procedure itself has not stood still. Rachna Hills records that the amendment to Regulation 17 which took effect on 12 March 2018 introduced a written examination into the selection of teachers in minority institutions (paragraph 17). A challenge to that amendment by aided minority institutions was reported in April 2020 as having been dismissed by a Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court, and an appeal against that decision was reported as entertained by the Supreme Court without a stay. The outcome of that appeal should be checked before either side relies on the 2020 ruling.

Dismissal: Where the Line Was Drawn

The disciplinary side of Article 30 was settled earlier, and the reasoning matters more than the result. In Frank Anthony Public School Employees' Association v. Union of India, (1986) 4 SCC 707, decided on 17 November 1986, the Supreme Court examined the Delhi School Education Act, 1973 as applied to a minority school. It held that Section 8(2), which required the Director of Education's prior approval before an employee was dismissed or removed, could not apply to a minority school, because it gave the Director an unguided power over the management's disciplinary decisions, of the kind struck down in the Ahmedabad St. Xavier's College case in 1974. In the same judgment it held that the employee's right of appeal to a Tribunal (Section 8(3)), the safeguards on suspension (Section 8(4)) and parity of pay with Government school teachers (Section 10) were valid regulations and did apply.

The distinction is between a veto and a safeguard. A provision that lets an officer approve or refuse a dismissal at his discretion takes disciplinary control away from the management. A provision that ensures a fair procedure, a remedy for the employee, or proper pay regulates that control without taking it away. In Y. Theclamma v. Union of India (15 April 1987), the Supreme Court applied the same reasoning to suspension and held that the requirement of prior approval for suspending an employee, read as a guided power, applies to an aided minority school.

The Uttar Pradesh case followed this line. In St. John Inter College (2001), the Supreme Court held that Section 16-G(3)(a) of the 1921 Act, which requires the prior approval of the Inspector for an order of dismissal, removal or termination of a teacher, does not apply to a minority institution. Its reasoning was twofold. The section contains no guidelines for the approving authority, and Regulation 44 only prescribes time limits, so the power is uncanalised. And Section 30 of the U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982 excluded minority institutions from that Act altogether, showing that the Legislature never intended a minority institution's termination orders to need such approval.

Two cautions follow. St. John decided whether approval was needed; it did not hold that a teacher of a minority college may be removed without a charge-sheet, an inquiry and an opportunity to answer. Frank Anthony shows that rules of fair procedure and an employee's remedy are permissible regulation. Second, the 1982 Act, including its Section 30, was repealed by Section 31 of the 2023 Act. The first and constitutional ground in St. John does not depend on the 1982 Act, and on this article's reading it continues to apply; but a management relying on St. John today should rest its case on that ground.

The Teacher's Side of the Same Rule

Article 30 is the management's right, but disputes under it are usually brought by teachers, and the same principles cut both ways. If you are a teacher in an aided minority school or college, the management's freedom to choose and to discipline does not displace the qualifications, pay scales and service conditions that the State prescribes, or the requirement of a fair inquiry before a major punishment. The DIOS's orders on approval, officiation or salary are open to challenge before the Allahabad High Court under Article 226, as Imtiyaz Ahamad itself shows. What a teacher cannot ordinarily insist on is that the DIOS must approve his dismissal before it takes effect; St. John is against that.

For a government servant, the procedure for a major penalty is governed by service rules such as the U.P. Government Servant (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999, discussed in a separate article on shrilaw.com. Teachers of aided private and minority institutions are governed by the 1921 Act, its Regulations and their terms of appointment, not by those Rules. The distinction should be settled before any challenge is drafted.

What Aid Allows the State to Add

The State's strongest ground for regulation is aid. In Frank Anthony itself the Supreme Court accepted parity of pay between minority school teachers and Government school teachers as a valid regulation. In Anjum Kadari v. Union of India, 2024 INSC 831 (5 November 2024), the Supreme Court upheld the Uttar Pradesh Board of Madarsa Education Act, 2004, which regulates, among other things, the standards of education and the qualifications of teachers in madrasas, while striking down its provisions on higher-education degrees (Fazil and Kamil) as in conflict with the UGC Act.

The decision that reaches furthest into selection is Sk. Md. Rafique v. Managing Committee, Contai Rahamania High Madrasah, (2020) 6 SCC 689, decided on 6 January 2020 by Arun Mishra and U.U. Lalit, JJ. The Supreme Court upheld the West Bengal Madrasah Service Commission Act, 2008, under which teachers of aided madrasahs are selected by a Commission and nominated to the institution. It held that the right of appointment is not absolute and unqualified. The Court divided minority institutions into two kinds: those whose teaching is directed at preserving the community's religion, culture, language or script, where the management is allowed the widest latitude, and those imparting secular education, where the aim must be the best available teachers (paragraph 47). A madrasah that has a better candidate than the nominee may reject the nomination; but rejecting a nominee who is better qualified and suitable is not within the protection of Article 30(1) (paragraph 50). Two features of the West Bengal law carried weight. The Commission had to include persons with profound knowledge of Islamic culture and theology (paragraph 52), which the Court said set the case apart from its earlier decisions on State nomination of teachers (paragraph 56); and the Managing Committee could point out an error in a nomination, including the availability of a better-qualified candidate, and could refuse a nominee on a reasonable ground (paragraph 53). On that basis Sections 8, 10, 11 and 12 of the Act were upheld (paragraph 57). A later petition under Article 32 seeking reconsideration of that judgment was dismissed with costs in 2025 (Managing Committee, Contai Rahamania High Madrasah v. State of West Bengal, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1823).

The management's answer deserves to be stated fairly. T.M.A. Pai was decided by eleven Judges, and Malankara, applying it, held that aid makes no difference to the choice of the Principal. Sk. Md. Rafique was decided by two Judges, on a West Bengal statute governing madrasahs, and rests on its reading of T.M.A. Pai's treatment of secular education. On this view, a scheme under which the management cannot select at all goes beyond regulating the right and begins to take it away. The State's reply is that the same eleven-Judge Bench allowed regulation in the interest of excellence, that Sk. Md. Rafique has been followed and has resisted reconsideration, and that a merit-based Commission treats minority and majority institutions alike. Each side can point to the Supreme Court. That is why the next question remains open.

The Open Question: The 2023 Commission Act

The 2023 Act brings this dispute to Uttar Pradesh. Section 2(1)(g) defines "institution" to include aided minority colleges affiliated to a State University, non-government aided minority intermediate colleges, higher secondary schools and high schools recognised under the 1921 Act, and aided minority junior high schools governed by the Basic Education Board. Section 12 provides that every appointment of a teacher shall be made by the appointing authority only on the recommendation of the Commission, and that an appointment in breach is void. For religious and linguistic minority institutions, Section 10(3) requires that the selection be completed by inviting educationists of that religion or language. Section 30 gives the Act overriding effect, in matters of selection, over the rules, regulations and Statutes under the education laws it lists.

The State's own approach has not been steady. Sunil Kumar Jain v. State of U.P., Writ-A No. 10333 of 2025, decided by the Lucknow Bench on 29 May 2026, concerned twenty-two posts of Assistant Professor in a Jain minority degree college in Baghpat, advertised in August 2023, days before the 2023 Act came into force. An order of 6 May 2024 directed that the selection be made through the new Commission; it was recalled in November 2024, both orders were set aside by the High Court in January 2025, and on 21 April 2025 the State decided that the selection would continue under the earlier law. The Court upheld that decision. It did not decide any question under Article 30. It held that because the advertisements were issued before the 2023 Act came into force, the earlier procedure applied (paragraphs 35 and 39), on the principle that a recruitment process begins with the advertisement and its rules cannot be changed midway. For a minority institution with a selection under way, the date of advertisement may therefore decide which regime applies.

Whether Section 12 can constitutionally apply to an aided minority institution, and how it sits with Section 16-FF of the 1921 Act, is the question this article has not found decided in any reported judgment of the Allahabad High Court or the Supreme Court at the time of writing. Sk. Md. Rafique itself supplies the test against which the Act will be measured. Section 10(3) corresponds to the first feature the Supreme Court relied on, the presence in the selection of experts from the minority's religion or language. This article has not found in the 2023 Act a provision corresponding to the second: a power in the management to show that it has a better candidate, or to refuse a nominee on a reasonable ground. The Act points the other way. Section 12 makes every appointment of a teacher depend on the Commission's recommendation and declares any other appointment void. Under Section 13, a recommended candidate who is not appointed in time may apply to the Director of Education, who may direct the appointing authority to appoint him with immediate effect, and the salary due may be recovered by the Collector, as arrears of land revenue, from the property of the society running the institution. Section 20 makes a management that fails to comply with the Commission's recommendation or the Director's direction liable to legal action. The State will say that the Supreme Court has already upheld Commission selection for aided minority institutions; a management will say that the safeguard on which that decision turned is missing here, and will rely on Malankara. The answer may differ between the head of the institution, whose choice the Supreme Court has protected most strongly, and assistant teachers; Section 12 speaks of the appointment of a "teacher or instructor", and its proviso leaves appointment by promotion, by transfer, and of dependants of employees dying in harness to the existing Acts and rules; whether, and how, it reaches the post of Principal of a minority institution may itself be argued.

A second, larger question is pending in the Supreme Court. In Anjuman Ishaat-e-Taleem Trust v. State of Maharashtra, 2025 INSC 1063 (1 September 2025), a Bench of Dipankar Datta and Manmohan, JJ. held the Teacher Eligibility Test to be a minimum qualification for teachers in schools covered by the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, expressed doubt about the Constitution Bench ruling in Pramati Educational and Cultural Trust v. Union of India, (2014) 8 SCC 1, which had held that Act inapplicable to all minority schools, aided or unaided, and referred the question to the Chief Justice for a larger Bench. Until the reference is decided, Pramati continues to bind, and minority schools remain outside the 2009 Act. If it is overruled, the qualifications prescribed under that Act would reach minority elementary schools as well.

What Papers Decide These Cases

For a Committee of Management, the documents that usually decide a service dispute are: the order recognising the institution's minority status and its founding record; the resolution constituting the Selection Committee and the record of its proceedings; the date of the advertisement and of the vacancy; the selected candidate's qualifications as on the date of the vacancy; and, in a disciplinary matter, the charge-sheet, the inquiry record and the opportunity given to the employee.

For a teacher, the corresponding papers are the appointment letter and the DIOS's approval, the order granting or refusing officiation or salary, the seniority list, and the full disciplinary record. Where the DIOS refuses approval of a selection, the three-week period for representation under Section 16-FF(5) should not be allowed to pass while other remedies are considered.

Conclusion

The position in Uttar Pradesh today is this. A minority management chooses its Principal and teachers from among qualified persons, and it disciplines its staff without needing an officer's prior approval for a dismissal; the State, in turn, fixes qualifications, pay and fair procedure, and it may attach further conditions to aid. What the State may not do, on the law as it stood when St. John was decided, is give an officer an unguided power to override the management. The 2023 Act tests whether a Commission that selects the teachers is a regulation of that kind or something more. Until the Allahabad High Court or the Supreme Court answers that question, and until the Pramati reference is decided, every minority institution in the State that makes a fresh appointment is acting on ground that may still shift.

Key Authorities Cited

  • C/M St. John Inter College v. Girdhari SinghSupreme Court of India, 2001-03-30(2001) 4 SCC 296; [2001] 2 S.C.R. 945; AIR 2001 SC 1891; Civil Appeal No. 5397 of 1997
  • Frank Anthony Public School Employees' Association v. Union of IndiaSupreme Court of India, 1986-11-17(1986) 4 SCC 707; [1987] 1 S.C.R. 238; Writ Petition (C) No. 587 of 1986
  • Y. Theclamma v. Union of IndiaSupreme Court of India, 1987-04-15[1987] 2 S.C.R. 974; Writ Petition (C) No. 1232 of 1986
  • Secretary, Malankara Syrian Catholic College v. T. JoseSupreme Court of India, 2006-11-27(2007) 1 SCC 386; AIR 2007 SC 570; Civil Appeal No. 8599 of 2003Paras: 19, 27
  • State of Uttar Pradesh v. Rachna HillsSupreme Court of India, 2023-04-272023 SCC OnLine SC 506; Civil Appeal Nos. 1882-1884 of 2023Paras: 17, 18, 19, 21, 23, 24, 25, 26
  • Imtiyaz Ahamad v. State of U.P.Allahabad High Court, 2023-10-312023:AHC:207384; Writ-A No. 11509 of 2023Paras: 30, 33
  • Sk. Md. Rafique v. Managing Committee, Contai Rahamania High MadrasahSupreme Court of India, 2020-01-06(2020) 6 SCC 689; Civil Appeal No. 5808 of 2017Paras: 47, 49, 50, 52, 53, 56, 57
  • Managing Committee, Contai Rahamania High Madrasah v. State of West BengalSupreme Court of India, 20252025 SCC OnLine SC 1823
  • Anjum Kadari v. Union of IndiaSupreme Court of India, 2024-11-052024 INSC 831; [2024] 11 S.C.R. 365
  • Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh AgarwalSupreme Court of India (Seven-Judge Bench), 2024-11-082024 INSC 856; [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1647; Civil Appeal No. 2286 of 2006
  • Anjuman Ishaat-e-Taleem Trust v. State of MaharashtraSupreme Court of India, 2025-09-012025 INSC 1063; Civil Appeal No. 1385 of 2025
  • Sunil Kumar Jain v. State of U.P.Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench), 2026-05-29Writ-A No. 10333 of 2025Paras: 35, 39

Statutory Provisions

  • Constitution of India - Article 30(1) and (2) (right of minorities to establish and administer educational institutions; non-discrimination in aid)
  • U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921 - Section 16-FF (selection and approval of Heads of Institutions and teachers in minority institutions), with Regulation 17 of Chapter II of the Regulations
  • U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921 - Section 16-G(3)(a) (prior approval of dismissal or removal; held inapplicable to minority institutions), with Regulation 44
  • Uttar Pradesh Education Service Selection Commission Act, 2023 (U.P. Act No. 15 of 2023) - Sections 2(1)(g), 10(3), 12, 13, 20, 30 and 31
  • U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board Act, 1982 (repealed by the 2023 Act) - Section 30 (exemption of minority institutions)
  • Delhi School Education Act, 1973 - Sections 8(2), 8(3), 8(4) and 10 (as examined in Frank Anthony)
  • Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 - Section 23 (minimum qualifications of teachers); application to minority schools under reference

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the DIOS have to approve the dismissal of a teacher in an aided minority intermediate college in U.P.?

No prior approval under Section 16-G(3)(a) of the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921 is required. In C/M St. John Inter College v. Girdhari Singh, (2001) 4 SCC 296, the Supreme Court held that provision inapplicable to minority institutions because it gives the approving authority no guidelines. This does not mean a teacher may be removed without a charge-sheet and a fair inquiry.

Can the management of a minority college choose its own Principal even though the college is government-aided?

Yes, from among persons who hold the qualifications and eligibility the State prescribes. The Supreme Court in Malankara Syrian Catholic College v. T. Jose (2006) held that receiving aid makes no difference to this choice. The Allahabad High Court in Imtiyaz Ahamad (2023) added that the person must be eligible on the date the vacancy arises, including for officiating charge.

Our selection committee chose a teacher but the DIOS has not approved the appointment for months. Is the appointment deemed approved?

Not under the 1921 Act. The Supreme Court held in State of U.P. v. Rachna Hills (27 April 2023) that Section 16-FF contains no deemed approval and that the selected candidate has no vested right until approval is given. The remedy is to press the DIOS for a decision and, if approval is refused, to represent to the Regional Deputy Director within three weeks under Section 16-FF(5), or approach the High Court.

Does the U.P. Education Service Selection Commission now select teachers for aided minority schools and colleges?

The 2023 Act, in force from 21 August 2023, includes aided minority institutions in its definition of "institution" and requires every teacher's appointment to be made on the Commission's recommendation, with educationists of the minority's religion or language included in the selection. Whether this is valid under Article 30 has not, as far as this article has found, been decided by the Allahabad High Court or the Supreme Court. Where the advertisement was issued before 21 August 2023, the Lucknow Bench held in Sunil Kumar Jain (29 May 2026) that the earlier procedure continues.

I am a teacher in a minority school. Does Article 30 mean the management can fix any salary it likes?

Not in an aided institution. The State may require pay and service conditions comparable to those in Government institutions; the Supreme Court accepted pay parity as a valid regulation in Frank Anthony Public School Employees' Association v. Union of India (1986). Article 30 protects the management's administration, not a right to pay less than the prescribed scales.

Do minority schools in U.P. have to follow the Right to Education Act and require TET for teachers?

At present the Constitution Bench ruling in Pramati (2014) keeps minority schools, aided and unaided, outside the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009. In Anjuman Ishaat-e-Taleem Trust (1 September 2025) the Supreme Court doubted that ruling and referred the question for a larger Bench; until it is decided, the exemption continues. Teachers in minority schools must still hold any qualifications prescribed under the State's own education laws.

Advocate Shashank Shri Tripathi
About the AuthorShashank Shri Tripathi, Advocate

Shri Law Chambers. Practises before the Supreme Court of India and in tribunal matters, including the Armed Forces Tribunal and the NCLT.

Enrolled with the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh, 2019 · Advocate-on-Record, Allahabad High Court · Allahabad High Court Bar Association